New: the Sitejar partner program

Dark Patterns

Fake Discounts and Inflated "Was" Prices: Is Your Sale Legal?

Fake Discounts and Inflated "Was" Prices: Are They Illegal?

Fake discounts are discounts measured against a price you never really charged. A sale is legal when the "was" price is one you actually charged recently. Inflating a price before a sale, or striking through a price nobody paid, can break the law in the US, the EU and the UK, and the EU sets an exact 30-day test.

This is the week it matters. Black Friday falls on November 27 and Cyber Monday on November 30, and most stores will show a crossed-out price next to a sale price on hundreds of products. When EU consumer authorities checked 314 online traders during Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales, in results published in March 2026, 30% got their discounts wrong. If you're setting sale prices this week, it's worth knowing which number you're allowed to cross out.

What makes a discount fake

A discount is fake when the price it's measured against isn't real. The sale price might be perfectly fine. The problem is the comparison: a crossed-out price that was never charged, charged only briefly, or charged by nobody at all.

There's nothing wrong with a genuine sale. If a product sold at $100 for months and you now sell it at $80, "Was $100, now $80" is true. If you never charged it, don't strike it through.

Here's how the common versions go wrong.

Common fake discount practices and why they mislead
PracticeExampleWhy it misleads
Raising the price just before a saleKogan raised prices on 621 products just before a 10%-off promotion in 2018The "discount" brings the price back to roughly where it was
Strikethrough price never chargedEmma Sleep admitted showing a struck-through price on a new product it had never offered at that priceThe customer is told about a saving that never existed
"Compare at" or "value" price that isn't a real former priceLamps Plus was accused of "Compare at", "Comparable Value" and strikethrough prices that weren't real former pricesThe reference looks like a market price but isn't one
A "was" price charged only for a few daysA product priced up for a week, then "discounted"A brief price isn't the real, regular price
A permanent or rolling sale"Sale" or "40% off" that never endsIf the sale price is always the price, the higher price isn't real
A percentage from the wrong starting pointAldi Süd calculated a reduction from a higher price than its 30-day lowThe EU's top court said the percentage must use the 30-day lowest price
Comparing against a recommended retail price nobody charges"RRP $199, our price $99" when nobody sells at $199The saving is against an estimate, not a real price; the EU's new proposal targets this
A discount shown while a cheaper bundle runsEmma admitted showing a higher comparison price while the product was cheaper in a parallel bundleThe customer could already buy it for less

Are fake discounts illegal? The short answer by region

Yes, in each of the main markets, but the tests differ a lot. The US relies on FTC guides plus stricter state rules. The EU has a precise 30-day lowest-price rule. The UK judges each case on whether the reference price misleads. Australia has fined a retailer for raising prices before a promotion.

How fake discounts are treated by region
WhereMain ruleEnforcement exampleWhat it means for you
US (federal)FTC Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, 16 CFR Part 233We found no recent FTC case on inflated former pricesGuides, not a rule, but they show how the FTC reads Section 5
CaliforniaBusiness and Professions Code section 17501Lamps Plus, $4.1 million stipulated judgment (2024)A former price must have prevailed in the 3 months before the ad, or its date must be stated
Massachusetts940 CMR 6.05Safe harbors set out in the regulationThe seller carries the burden of proving its former price was genuine
UKMisleading actions and omissions under the DMCC Act 2024; CTSI pricing guidanceEmma Sleep (2026, a partial setback for the CMA); Wayfair and Appliances Direct fines (2026, time-limit cases)Case by case: is the comparison price genuine and recent?
EUPrice Indication Directive, Article 6aAldi Süd, Court of Justice of the EU (2024)The prior price is your lowest price in the previous 30 days
EU (proposed)Digital Fairness ActProposed November 11, 2026, not lawWould stop comparisons against recommended retail prices
AustraliaAustralian Consumer LawACCC v Kogan, A$350,000 penalty (2020)Raising prices before a promotion is misleading

The US: FTC guides, and stricter state rules

In the US, the federal standard is a set of guides, and the sharper rules come from the states. Under section 233.1 of the FTC Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, a former price is a legitimate basis for a comparison "if the former price is the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time." If the former price is fictitious, for example inflated so a large "reduction" can be advertised, the bargain is false.

The guides add a nuance that matters for slow-selling products. A former price isn't necessarily fictitious just because nothing sold at it. It does have to have been openly and actively offered, for a reasonably substantial period, in the recent regular course of business, honestly and in good faith.

These are guides, not a rule. Under the FTC's own regulations, guides are administrative interpretations of the law, and failing to follow them can lead to action under Section 5 of the FTC Act. We found no recent FTC case on fake "was" prices. That's not a reason to relax, because the states are where the risk sits.

California is the strictest. Under Business and Professions Code section 17501, no price may be advertised as a former price unless it was the prevailing market price within the 3 months immediately before the ad, or unless the ad clearly, exactly and conspicuously states the date when that former price prevailed. "Prevailing market price" means the market price in the area, not just what you charged.

Massachusetts takes a different route. Under 940 CMR 6.05, a seller's own former price must be bona fide and actual, offered openly and in good faith for a reasonably substantial period in the recent past, and the seller carries the burden of proof. The regulation gives three safe harbors. Meeting any one is enough, and they aren't the only lawful route.

Massachusetts safe harbors for a seller's own former price
Safe harborWhat it requires
Share of salesThe former price was charged on at least 40% of sales in the 6 months before the ad
Recent 14 daysThe former price was offered openly and in good faith for the 14 days immediately before the ad
28 of 90 daysThe former price was offered for at least 28 of the 90 days before the ad, or of any 90-day period in the prior 12 months, with that date or period disclosed

New Jersey's consumer fraud regulations also prohibit fictitious former prices.

The clearest recent US case came from local prosecutors. On October 9, 2024, the District Attorneys of Los Angeles, Riverside, San Diego and San Bernardino counties announced a $4.1 million stipulated judgment against Lamps Plus, made up of $3.8 million in civil penalties and $300,000 in costs. They alleged misleading "Compare at", "Comparable Value" and strikethrough prices that weren't real former prices. Lamps Plus didn't admit liability.

One more point for online stores. These state rules protect consumers in that state, so a store based elsewhere that sells online to buyers in California or Massachusetts may be in scope. How far each rule reaches depends on the facts, so if most of your sales cross state lines, ask your counsel.

The EU: the 30-day lowest-price rule

The EU has the most precise rule of all: when you announce a price reduction, you must show the prior price, and the prior price is your lowest price in the previous 30 days. That comes from Article 6a of the Price Indication Directive, added by the Omnibus Directive (EU) 2019/2161 and applied since May 28, 2022. In its words, "the prior price means the lowest price applied by the trader during a period of time not shorter than 30 days prior to the application of the price reduction."

Member States can set different rules for goods that perish quickly, for products on the market for less than 30 days, and for progressive reductions, where the prior price is the price before the first reduction. Those are national options, not automatic exceptions, so check the country you're selling into.

The Court of Justice of the EU confirmed how strict this is in Aldi Süd (C-330/23) on September 26, 2024. Aldi advertised a reduction calculated from €1.69, the price just before the offer, while its lowest price in the previous 30 days was €1.29, the same as the "reduced" price. The court said a percentage discount, or a promotional statement stressing a good price, must be calculated from the 30-day lowest price. Showing the 30-day low somewhere on the label isn't enough if the percentage is worked out from a higher number.

The rule is widely missed. In the EU check of 314 online traders during Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales, published on March 26, 2026, 30% referenced discounts incorrectly against the 30-day rule. 34% showed price comparisons, and 60% of those didn't explain where the comparison price came from.

The next change is already proposed. On November 11, 2026, the European Commission proposed the Digital Fairness Act. A recital in the proposal says percentage-off, absolute-saving and struck-through prices should only compare against a verifiable price of the same product charged by a specific competitor, or a new product against a second-hand one, and not against estimated or recommended prices such as the manufacturer's recommended retail price. The 30-day rule stays as it is. It's a proposal that the European Parliament and the Council still have to agree on, not law.

Why should a US store care? Because the rule follows the customer. If you sell to shoppers in the EU, your "30% off" has to be measured from your 30-day low for them, whatever your US pages say.

The UK: case by case, and Emma Sleep shows why

The UK doesn't set a fixed day count. A reference price is judged under the general rules on misleading actions and omissions in the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 regime, in force since April 6, 2025, and explained in the CMA's guidance, CMA207.

The practical yardstick is the Chartered Trading Standards Institute's Guidance for Traders on Pricing Practices, which is non-statutory and was updated in April 2026. It sets out factors rather than fixed numbers. A reference price from less than 2 months ago, with no prices in between, is more likely to comply. You should compare with the last price you charged. The comparison period shouldn't be much longer than the period the higher price applied. Repeatedly using a higher price at which few units sold is less likely to comply. The CMA also set out its expectations in an open letter on urgency and price reduction claims on March 29, 2023.

The Emma Sleep case shows how much room that leaves. In CMA v Emma Matratzen GmbH, decided on July 30, 2026 under the older consumer law rather than the DMCC Act, Emma admitted 3 kinds of breach. It had shown a struck-through price on a new product never offered at that price. It had used a reference price that wasn't the price charged just before the promotion. And it had used one while a cheaper bundle promotion ran at the same time.

Beyond those admissions, the CMA lost ground. The court found no wider infringement. It refused the CMA's proposed rule that a trader should make 1 sale at the reference price for every 2 at the discount. It said low sales at that price aren't automatically misleading where the trader genuinely believes it's a realistic price. The CMA temporarily withdrew its mattress pricing principles after the judgment. It's fair to call it a partial setback for the regulator: the admitted practices are clearly off-limits, but there's no hard sales ratio.

The CMA has used its new powers on related tactics. On October 14, 2026, it fined Wayfair £4.8 million over "Daily Deals" and "Flash Deals" that didn't end when stated, and fined Appliances Direct £1.2 million, plus about £432,000 in refunds, over repeated "limited time" discount offers and pre-selected paid extras. These were cases about fake time limits on discounts, not fake "was" prices. They still show that a discount claim, whatever kind, is now something the CMA fines directly.

One worked example: what discount can you claim?

The quickest way to see how the rules differ is to run one price history through all of them. Take a product you've sold at $100 for months. Ten days before your sale, you raise it to $130. On Black Friday, you advertise it at $91 as "30% off $130".

The maths of the claim works: $91 is 30% below $130. The problem is that $130 isn't a price you really charged. Here's how each rule sees it.

Worked example, one price history under four rules
RulePrior or reference price you can useLawful claim?Why
EU 30-day rule$100, your lowest price in the previous 30 daysNo. The real reduction is 9%, not 30%Article 6a and Aldi Süd require the percentage to be calculated from the 30-day low
Massachusetts safe harborsNone for $130Unlikely$130 ran for 10 days: under the 14 days, under 28 of 90 days, and unlikely to be 40% of sales in 6 months
California 3-month ruleNot $130No$130 wasn't the prevailing market price for the 3 months before the ad
UK CTSI factors$100, the price charged for monthsRisky with $130$130 was brief and recent; comparing with $100 is the safer claim

So the lawful version of this sale is "Was $100, now $91", a 9% reduction, and in most of these places that's the only version you can defend. If 9% doesn't sound like a Black Friday deal, the answer is a deeper real discount, not a higher fake starting point.

This is a simplified illustration, not legal advice.

How common fake discounts are

Fake discounts and badly explained ones are common enough that regulators test for them at every major sale. The EU check of 314 online traders found that 30% referenced discounts incorrectly against the 30-day rule. Of the 34% that showed price comparisons, 60% didn't say where the comparison price came from.

Scale is the other signal. In the Kogan case in Australia, the retailer raised prices on 621 products, mostly by at least 10%, just before a 10%-off "TAXTIME" promotion in June 2018. The Federal Court ordered a A$350,000 penalty on December 7, 2020. When a price rise is applied to a whole catalog at once, it stops looking like an accident.

Black Friday: discounts rarely travel alone

A holiday sale page rarely relies on one pressure tactic. The inflated crossed-out price is often the first of several, each making the next one easier.

The pattern looks like this. A product shows a struck-through price that was quietly raised the week before, with "30% off" in red. Next to it, a timer says the deal ends tonight, but it starts over for every new visitor. Below the price, a badge says only 3 are left. The customer adds to cart, and at the last step a service fee appears. Every element points the same way: decide now, don't compare, don't check the total.

Regulators look at these tactics side by side. Wayfair's fine, for example, was about deals that didn't end when stated. Each tactic has its own rules, and we've covered them separately: countdown timers that reset, fake low-stock warnings and hidden fees added at checkout. All of them are among the manipulative designs regulators are targeting.

The fix is the same across all of them, and it doesn't need a redesign. Show a real previous price, end the sale when you say it ends, show stock levels only when they're true and put every mandatory fee in the price. A sale built that way gives a regulator very little to work with, and a genuine discount still sells.

How to run an honest sale

An honest sale starts with records. If you know what you charged and when, every discount claim becomes a lookup rather than a guess.

Keep a price history for every product

Log every price change with its date, for every product you might promote. Most store platforms keep some of this, but not always in a form you can show someone. A simple export before each sale is enough. If a customer, a platform or a regulator asks where a sale price came from, you'll have the answer.

Use your lowest 30-day price for EU customers

For EU shoppers, the reference price is your lowest price in the 30 days before the discount, and the percentage must be calculated from it. If your platform can't calculate that automatically, work it out from your price history before the sale and set it by hand.

Date your "was" prices, or keep them recent

California lets you use an older former price if you clearly state when it applied. Otherwise it has to have prevailed in the previous 3 months. "Was $100 (price from August 1 to October 31)" is longer than "Was $100", and much easier to defend.

Don't raise prices before a sale

A price rise in the weeks before a promotion is exactly what Kogan was penalized for, and exactly what the worked example above shows going wrong. If you need margin for the sale, choose a smaller discount from the real price.

A "compare at" price should be a real price for the same product in the market, and you should be able to show where it came from. Recommended retail prices that nobody actually charges are risky now and would be off-limits in the EU under the Digital Fairness Act proposal.

End the sale when you say it ends

If the banner says the sale ends Monday, end it Monday. A sale that quietly continues, or restarts the next day at the same price, turns a time claim into a false one, which is what the CMA fined Wayfair for.

A pricing checklist before your sale

Run your top promoted products through this table before the sale goes live.

Pre-sale pricing checklist
CheckPassFailFix
Every "was" price was actually chargedYour price history shows itYou can't find it in your recordsUse the last price you really charged
It was charged recently and for a meaningful periodWeeks or months, not daysIt applied for a few daysUse the longer-standing price
No price rise before the salePrices were steady in the weeks beforePrices went up shortly before the promotionReset the reference to the earlier price
Percentage from the right starting priceThe 30-day low for EU customersCalculated from a higher recent priceRecalculate from the 30-day low
"Compare at" prices are real market pricesYou can show a real seller at that priceIt's an estimate or an old supplier figureRemove it or replace it with a verified price
No RRP comparison unless that price is chargedRetailers actually sell at that priceNobody sells at the RRPDrop the RRP comparison
The sale has a real end dateIt ends when statedIt keeps running after the deadlineSet and keep a real end date
No rolling "permanent" saleSale prices are temporaryThe product is always "on sale"Make the sale price the regular price
"Limited time" codes really are limitedThe code expires as statedThe code keeps reappearingExpire codes on schedule
Price history savedYou've exported prices for every promoted productNo record of past pricesExport it before the sale starts

Run a free website scan of your sale pages and checkout to check for deceptive design, accessibility, cookie consent and security issues in one pass.

The rest of your store: accessibility, cookies and security

Sale pages get more visitors than usual, and not all of them use a mouse and a large screen. People using screen readers, keyboards and phones need to reach the price, the product options and the checkout, and inaccessible stores are a common target of ADA demand letters. A sale price shown only as red text, or a crossed-out price a screen reader can't make sense of, is an accessibility problem as well as a clarity one. Run your product and checkout pages through the free website accessibility checker, then use the ADA website compliance checklist for the checks a tool can't judge. If you publish an accessibility statement, the accessibility statement generator gives you a draft to edit.

Many stores add marketing tags and tracking pixels before a sale. Use the cookie consent checker to see what loads before a visitor makes a consent choice.

Checkout pages are where an injected script does the most harm, so they need the right security headers. The free security headers checker shows which headers a page sends and which are missing.

If you're an agency preparing several client stores, white-label compliance reports for agencies let you send each client the findings under your own name.

Common questions

These are the questions we hear most from store owners and shoppers about sale prices.

Is it illegal to raise prices before a sale?

It can be, if you then advertise the discount against the raised price. The EU's 30-day rule makes the raised price irrelevant, because the reduction must be measured from your lowest price in the previous 30 days. Australia's Federal Court penalized Kogan for raising 621 prices before a promotion, and California and Massachusetts both require a former price to be genuine and recent.

How long does a "was" price have to apply?

It depends on where your customer is. In the EU, the reference is your lowest price in the previous 30 days. In California, the former price must have prevailed in the 3 months before the ad, unless you state its date. Massachusetts gives safe harbors such as 14 days immediately before the ad or 28 of the last 90 days, and the UK's CTSI guidance treats a recent price that applied for a meaningful period as more likely to comply.

Can I use "compare at" or MSRP prices?

Only carefully. A "compare at" price should be a real market price for the same product, and the Lamps Plus judgment shows what happens when it isn't. Comparisons against a manufacturer's recommended price nobody actually charges are risky today, and the EU's Digital Fairness Act proposal would rule them out.

Does the EU 30-day rule apply to a US store?

If you sell to consumers in the EU, the rules of the country they're in protect them, so your discounts for those customers should follow the 30-day rule. The simplest approach for a store selling internationally is to use the 30-day low as your starting price everywhere.

Is a permanent sale illegal?

A sale that never ends means the sale price is really the regular price, so the higher price it's compared against isn't genuine. Under the FTC guides, a former price has to be one you actually offered on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period, and a permanent sale fails that test.

What if almost nobody bought at the full price?

That alone doesn't make the price fake. Section 233.1 of the FTC guides says a former price isn't necessarily fictitious just because no sales were made at it, as long as it was openly and actively offered in good faith. In the UK, the Emma Sleep court refused a fixed sales ratio and said low sales aren't automatically misleading where the trader genuinely believes the price is realistic, though CTSI guidance still treats repeated use of a higher price with few sales as less likely to comply.

This article is general information, not legal advice.

Get your sale ready

You don't have to drop discounts to stay safe. You need a real "was" price for every product you promote, the right reference price for each market and a sale that ends when you say it does.

Before Black Friday, scan your store free, then run the pricing checklist above on your best-selling products. There's more on dark patterns on our blog.

Sources

Sources cited in this article
SourceWhat it supportsLink
eCFR via govinfo, 16 CFR Part 233FTC Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, section 233.1govinfo.gov
eCFR via govinfo, 16 CFR 1.5FTC guides are administrative interpretationsgovinfo.gov
California Legislative InformationBusiness and Professions Code section 17501leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
Massachusetts Attorney General940 CMR 6.05 and its safe harborsmass.gov
New Jersey Administrative CodeN.J.A.C. 13:45A-9justia.com
California District Attorneys, October 9, 2024Lamps Plus $4.1 million stipulated judgmentdanewscenter.com
EU Publications Office, Directive (EU) 2019/2161Article 6a, 30-day prior price rulepublications.europa.eu
Court of Justice of the EU, September 26, 2024Aldi Süd, C-330/23curia.europa.eu
European Commission, March 26, 2026EU check of 314 online traderscommission.europa.eu
European Commission, Digital Fairness Act proposalRecital on recommended retail price comparisonscommission.europa.eu
CMA, CMA207 guidanceUK misleading actions and omissionsgov.uk
Chartered Trading Standards InstituteGuidance for Traders on Pricing Practicesbusinesscompanion.info
CMA, March 29, 2023Open letter on urgency and price reduction claimsgov.uk
High Court, July 30, 2026CMA v Emma Matratzen GmbH [2026] EWHC 1995 (Ch)gov.uk
CMA, Emma Group case pageWithdrawal of mattress pricing principlesgov.uk
CMA, October 14, 2026Wayfair and Appliances Direct finesgov.uk
ACCC, December 7, 2020Kogan A$350,000 penaltyaccc.gov.au

This article is educational and reflects Sitejar's point of view. It is not legal advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified attorney.

All articles