New: the Sitejar partner program

Dark Patterns

Drip Pricing and Hidden Fees: Is Your Checkout Breaking the Law?

Drip Pricing: Is It Illegal? Hidden Fee Laws Explained

Drip pricing is advertising a low price and adding mandatory fees later in checkout. It's now banned for almost every business selling to consumers in several US states and in the UK. The FTC's own fee rule is much narrower than the headlines suggest, and the EU is tightening its rules.

The timing matters. Black Friday falls on November 27 and Cyber Monday on November 30, which is exactly when checkouts get rushed changes and new "service" lines. In the past 2 weeks alone, the UK's competition regulator wrote to online retailers about delivery fees and the European Commission proposed new rules on hidden fees, after a year in which the FTC collected tens of millions of dollars over junk fees. If you're about to run a sale, this is the week to look at your checkout.

What drip pricing is, and what it isn't

It means a fee the customer can't avoid shows up after the first price they saw. The test is simple: could the customer buy the thing without paying this fee? If not, the fee is mandatory, and a mandatory fee belongs in the price. That's the whole rule in most places.

Optional extras are different. Gift wrap, express shipping or a warranty the customer actively chooses aren't dripped fees, because the advertised price was the real price of the thing. The trouble starts when an "optional" extra is pre-selected, so the customer has to notice it and opt out. Regulators treat that as its own problem.

Shipping and card surcharges sit in the gray zone, and the answer depends on where your customer is. Here's how common checkout fees usually fall.

Common checkout fees and when they become a problem
FeeTypical label at checkoutIs it mandatory?Is it drip pricing if added late?
Service fee"Service fee", "Platform fee"Usually yesYes. The FTC also warns that vague labels like "service fee" can mislead on their own
Convenience or booking fee"Convenience fee", "Booking fee"Yes, if every buyer pays itYes. The UK's first DMCC fine was over a £3 booking fee
Resort or destination fee"Resort fee", "Destination fee"YesYes, and in the US it falls squarely under the FTC Fees Rule for lodging
Mandatory delivery or collection fee"Delivery", "Collection fee"Yes, when there's no free way to get the itemIn the UK, yes: the CMA said in November 2026 that the minimum mandatory delivery charge must be in the total price
Handling fee"Handling", "Processing"Usually yesYes in California, which counts handling fees as part of the price
Credit card surcharge"Card fee", "Surcharge"Only if card is the only way to payIt depends on the law and on whether cheaper payment options exist. Treat it carefully
Shipping"Shipping"OftenIt varies: several US states exclude reasonable shipping, the UK expects mandatory delivery in the total
Optional insurance or warranty"Protection plan", "Insurance"NoNot if truly optional. A pre-ticked box is its own violation in the EU
Pre-selected tip or support upgrade"Tip", "VIP Support"Presented as optionalThe FTC alleged Hopper pre-selected these and left them out of the total

Is drip pricing illegal? The short answer by region

Yes in a growing number of places, and the rules differ more than most summaries admit. In the US, a narrow federal rule covers tickets and lodging, the FTC Act covers deception everywhere, and a set of state laws require total pricing for almost every business. The UK bans it outright. The EU already requires clear total prices and has proposed more.

Hidden fee rules by region
WhereRuleIn force sinceWho it coversWhat you must do
US (federal)FTC Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees, 16 CFR Part 464May 12, 2025Live-event tickets and short-term lodging, including resellers and platformsShow the total price, most prominently, wherever a price appears
US (federal)Section 5 of the FTC ActLong-standingEvery businessDon't deceive customers about what they'll pay
CaliforniaSB 478, Civil Code 1770(a)(29)July 1, 2024Businesses advertising to California consumersInclude all mandatory fees in the advertised price
MinnesotaMinn. Stat. 325D.44January 1, 2025Businesses advertising to Minnesota consumersNo displayed price may leave out mandatory fees
VirginiaVa. Code 59.1-607 to 59.1-609July 1, 2025Businesses advertising to Virginia consumersShow the total price clearly and conspicuously
Massachusetts940 CMR 38.00September 2, 2025Businesses offering to Massachusetts consumersTotal price first and most prominent, before collecting personal data
ColoradoHB25-1090January 1, 2026Any good, service or propertyDisclose the maximum total price with any price shown
OregonSB 4302026Online sellersDon't advertise a price that leaves out mandatory fees
ConnecticutPublic Act 25-44July 1, 2026Businesses advertising to Connecticut consumersInclude all fees and charges except taxes and government fees
IllinoisHB 228January 1, 2027Businesses advertising to Illinois consumersInclude all mandatory fees and surcharges before taxes
UKDMCC Act 2024, section 230April 6, 2025Traders selling to UK consumersTotal price including unavoidable fees in every invitation to purchase
EUUnfair Commercial Practices Directive and Consumer Rights DirectiveLong-standingTraders selling to EU consumersPrices inclusive of taxes and delivery; express consent for extra payments
EUDigital Fairness ActProposed November 11, 2026, not lawWould cover traders selling to EU consumersNothing yet; watch the negotiations

The FTC fees rule is narrower than most headlines suggest

The FTC's Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees covers only two industries: live-event tickets and short-term lodging. The FTC announced it on December 17, 2024, it was published on January 10, 2025, and it took effect on May 12, 2025. It reaches hotels, motels, short-term and vacation rentals and event tickets, including third-party platforms and resellers. According to the FTC's own FAQ on the rule, it does not cover general e-commerce, SaaS or retail. "The FTC banned junk fees" is the most common half-truth on this topic.

Inside its scope, the rule is strict. Whenever a price is shown, the total price, meaning every mandatory fee, has to be there and has to be more prominent than other pricing information. Before payment, any fee not in the total has to be disclosed with its nature, purpose and amount, along with the final amount. Fees can never be misrepresented, and the FAQ warns that vague labels like "service fee" or "convenience fee" can be misleading. Government charges, shipping and genuinely optional add-ons can stay out of the total. The rule also doesn't override state laws that protect consumers more.

Knowing violations of an FTC rule can bring civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation, and the FTC kept its 2025 penalty levels for 2026. On a ticketing site or a booking platform, "per violation" adds up fast.

Here's the part that matters for everyone else. Section 5 of the FTC Act bans deceptive practices by any business, rule or no rule, and that's what most recent fee cases relied on.

FTC enforcement actions on fees, 2025 to 2026
DateCompanyWhat the FTC allegedOutcome
Sept 18, 2025Live Nation and Ticketmaster (with 7 states)Fees of up to 44% of the ticket price and $16.4 billion in fees from 2019 to 2024Lawsuit pending; these are allegations, not findings
Dec 2, 2025Greystar (with Colorado)Hidden mandatory rental fees$24 million
Dec 18, 2025Instacart"Free delivery" advertised while a mandatory service fee added up to 15%$60 million in consumer refunds
Apr 9, 2026StubHubUnder the Fees Rule: ticket prices that left out mandatory fees$10 million in refunds
Jul 2, 2026HopperPre-selected, hidden "Tip" and "VIP Support" fees; the Fees Rule for lodging bookings$35 million
Aug 19, 2026Manchester City Nissan (with Connecticut)Deceptive fees and add-ons$4 million

Look at that table again. A grocery app, a landlord and a car dealer are on it, and none of them sells tickets or rooms. Only StubHub and part of the Hopper case leaned on the Fees Rule. The rest came from plain deception law, which is why "the rule doesn't cover my store" isn't the end of the conversation.

The FTC is also looking at more sectors. It has asked for public comment on fees in online food and grocery delivery (April 2026) and in rental housing (March 2026). Both are early-stage notices, not rules.

The state laws that reach almost every business

State junk fee laws are where most online stores and SaaS companies are actually exposed, because they apply to almost any good or service. Here's what's in force or coming.

State junk fee laws that cover almost every business
StateLawIn forceCore rule
CaliforniaSB 478, Civil Code 1770(a)(29)July 1, 2024Advertised price must include all mandatory fees. Government taxes and fees and reasonable shipping are excluded; handling fees must be included. Restaurants may show a mandatory fee separately if clearly displayed
MinnesotaMinn. Stat. 325D.44January 1, 2025No advertised or displayed price may leave out mandatory fees or surcharges. Government taxes excluded
VirginiaVa. Code 59.1-607 to 59.1-609July 1, 2025Total price including all mandatory fees, shown clearly and conspicuously whenever a price is advertised. Taxes and reasonable shipping excluded
Massachusetts940 CMR 38.00September 2, 2025Total price shown more prominently than other prices, at first presentation and before asking for personal data; also covers trial offers and auto-renewals
ColoradoHB25-1090January 1, 2026No price may be shown unless the maximum total price is clearly disclosed, for any good, service or property. Government charges and shipping excluded unless included voluntarily
OregonSB 430, "No Hidden Online Fees"2026Online sellers may not advertise a price that leaves out mandatory fees
ConnecticutPublic Act 25-44July 1, 2026Advertised price must include all fees and charges; taxes and government fees excluded
IllinoisHB 228January 1, 2027Advertised prices must include all mandatory fees and surcharges before taxes, with specific rules for delivery, rideshare, lodging, restaurants and tickets

The broad idea is the same everywhere: if every buyer pays it, it's in the price. The details aren't. Each law draws its own exceptions, and "taxes and shipping are always excluded" isn't true across the board. Shipping is the most common trap. California and Virginia exclude reasonable shipping, Colorado excludes shipping charges, and California still counts a separate handling fee as part of the price. If your checkout splits "shipping" into "shipping" and "handling", the second line can be the one that causes trouble.

Where your company is based isn't the whole question. These laws protect consumers in their state, so a store based in Texas that sells online to buyers in California, Minnesota or Colorado may well be in scope. How far each law reaches out of state depends on the statute and the facts, so treat this as a question for your counsel rather than something to settle from a blog post. The practical answer most national stores reach is simpler: show the total price everywhere, and you don't have to sort customers by state.

Illinois starts on January 1, 2027. Put a reminder in the calendar for early January to check your pricing again, especially if you sell delivery, rideshare, lodging, restaurant or ticketing services, which get their own rules there.

Two states come up often and don't belong on the broad list. Maine's 2025 law covers only short-term lodging and event tickets. New York State has no broad junk fee law, though New York City banned hidden hotel fees from February 21, 2026.

The UK: drip pricing has been illegal since April 2025

Since April 6, 2025, the UK has banned dripped fees for anyone selling to UK consumers, under the consumer protection provisions of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024. The rule is section 230 of the Act. An invitation to purchase must state the total price, including any fees, taxes or charges the consumer will necessarily pay. If part of the price can't be calculated in advance, you have to explain how it's calculated, as prominently as the price itself.

What changed the stakes is enforcement. The Competition and Markets Authority can now fine a business up to 10% of global turnover without going to court first. Its first fine under the new powers came on April 15, 2026: the AA and BSM driving schools paid £4.2 million and refunded more than £760,000 to over 80,000 customers, all over a mandatory £3 booking fee left out of the upfront price. On August 19, 2026, the CMA opened investigations into dripped fees into Trainline, Virgin Atlantic and RED Driving School.

Then, on November 2, 2026, the CMA sent an open letter to online retailers. Its message: when delivery or collection is mandatory, that fee belongs in the total price, and the total including the minimum mandatory delivery charge has to be shown throughout the sales process. The letter also reports that the CMA has taken drip pricing action against 4 businesses so far, with fines of more than £5.1 million and refunds of more than £1.35 million. The detail is in the CMA's guidance on unfair commercial practices (CMA207).

Why should a US store care? Because the law follows the customer. If you ship to the UK and your product page shows a price that becomes £8 more at the last step, the £3 that cost the AA £4.2 million is a useful comparison.

The EU: today's rules and the Digital Fairness Act

EU law already requires the price a shopper sees to be the real one. Under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC), an invitation to purchase has to show the price inclusive of taxes and delivery charges, and hiding fees until late can count as a misleading omission. Under Article 22 of the Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU), a trader needs the consumer's express consent for any extra payment, and pre-ticked boxes for extras are banned.

Enforcement is active. In a Black Friday and Cyber Monday sweep published on March 26, 2026, the European Commission and national consumer authorities checked 314 online traders. 30% displayed discounts incorrectly and 36% tried to add optional items to the basket.

On November 11, 2026, the European Commission proposed the Digital Fairness Act, which targets manipulative online practices including hidden fees and calls for clear and transparent pricing. It's a proposal. The European Parliament and the Council still have to agree on it, and nothing in it binds anyone yet. What it does tell you is the direction of travel: the EU isn't loosening anything.

How common hidden fees are

Hidden fees are common enough that regulators treat them as a mainstream problem, not an edge case. The best measurement comes from the UK. In research published on September 4, 2023, the Department for Business and Trade found that 46% of 525 online and app providers it sampled included at least one dripped fee, not counting delivery. It estimated that these fees cost UK consumers an extra £595 million to £3.5 billion a year online.

The EU sweep tells a similar story at Black Friday scale: 10% of the 314 traders checked used drip pricing. In the US, the FTC's analysis in the final Fees Rule counted the cost of lodging fees in time, estimating 27.2 to 39.6 million consumer hours a year saved from not hunting for hidden fees.

Black Friday is where drip pricing meets fake urgency

Holiday checkouts rarely use one dark pattern at a time. They stack them, and each layer makes the next one work better.

It usually starts on the product page. A countdown says the deal ends in 14 minutes, which pushes the shopper to decide fast. The headline price is low, often a little lower than competitors, because the fees haven't arrived yet. Then the customer commits: they add to cart, type an email, enter an address. Only at the last step does a service fee, a handling fee or a mandatory delivery charge appear. By then the timer is still running and the shopper has already invested 5 minutes. Some pay just to be done. And somewhere in the basket, a protection plan or a donation was ticked by default.

Every piece of that sequence is something a regulator has acted on. Pressure from a timer that resets or lies about the deadline is the subject of our piece on fake countdown timers. The late fee is the dripped fee. The pre-ticked add-on breaks the EU's express consent rule and featured in the Hopper case. And an "only 2 left" badge that isn't tied to real stock is false scarcity, which regulators treat as deception too. Taken together, they're a short version of the seven manipulative designs regulators are targeting.

There's a reason the combination is risky. A fair price with a real deadline is ordinary marketing. A low price that grows at the last step, under a timer that isn't real, is the pattern regulators describe in their complaints. If your sale has a real end date, show it. If your price has mandatory fees, show them up front. Neither costs you a legitimate sale.

Subscriptions add one more layer. A holiday offer that quietly turns into a recurring charge, with a cancellation process harder than the signup, is its own category of trouble. The federal FTC click-to-cancel rule was vacated, but the obligations behind it didn't disappear, and Massachusetts's fee regulation covers trial offers and auto-renewals too.

A 15-minute checkout audit before your sale

Open your store in a private window, put a typical order in the cart and go through every step with this table.

15-minute checkout audit
CheckPassFailFix
Total price on product and category pagesThe price shown includes every mandatory feeA fee appears only in the cart or at checkoutFold the fee into the listed price
Total price in ads and emailsAd and email prices match the checkout totalPromotions show a base price without feesUpdate ad and email templates to the total price
First price shown includes mandatory feesThe first number a shopper sees is what they'll pay, before taxes where allowedThe first number grows as they goCalculate fees before the first display
No new mandatory fee in the last stepThe final screen adds nothing that wasn't shown earlierA "service" or "processing" line appears at paymentMove the fee into the price or remove it
Delivery or collection fee for UK customersThe minimum mandatory delivery charge is in the total shownDelivery appears only at the end for a UK orderShow the total including minimum delivery throughout
Fee names describe the feeEach fee says what it pays for"Service fee" or "convenience fee" with no explanationRename and explain, or fold it into the price
No pre-ticked add-onsEvery extra starts unselectedInsurance, donations or upgrades are pre-checkedUntick by default; let customers opt in
Tips and support upgrades not pre-selectedTips start at zero and upgrades are offA tip or "priority support" is already addedSet to zero or off by default
Total price is the most prominent priceThe total is the biggest price on the pageA base price in large type, the total in small printSwap the visual weight
Price breakdown before paymentCustomers can see what makes up the total before they payThe breakdown appears only on the receiptAdd an expandable breakdown above the pay button
Discount claims match a real previous price"Was" prices are real prices you chargedStrike-through prices nobody ever paidUse the actual previous price, and in the EU the lowest price in the past 30 days
Countdown timers reflect a real deadlineThe timer ends when the offer actually endsThe timer resets on reload or for each visitorTie the timer to the real end date, or remove it

Run a free website scan to check your checkout pages for deceptive design, accessibility, cookie consent and security issues.

A scan reads each page the way a first-time visitor's browser receives it, so it won't fill a cart and walk your payment steps for you. That's what the table above is for.

How to fix drip pricing without hurting conversion

The fix is to show the real price earlier, and it doesn't have to cost you sales. Shoppers who aren't surprised at the last step have one less reason to abandon the cart or write to support. Here's how to do it without redesigning everything.

Put the total price first

Make the total the first and largest price on the page. If you want to show a breakdown, put it under the total, in smaller type. Most of the rules above care about which number a shopper sees first and which one stands out.

Fold mandatory fees into the price

If every customer pays a fee, stop showing it as a fee. Raise the item price by the same amount and delete the line. It's the simplest fix, it's the one regulators expect, and it removes the awkward moment at checkout.

Make optional extras truly optional

Start every extra unselected: insurance, donations, priority handling, tips. Let customers add what they want. An extra a customer chose is a sale. An extra they didn't notice is a refund request, or worse.

Name every fee for what it is

If a charge really is separate, say what it pays for in plain words. "Delivery to your door" tells the customer something. "Service fee" tells them nothing, and the FTC has said vague labels like that can mislead on their own.

Explain variable costs like shipping and tax

Some costs depend on the customer's address. Where you can't show them up front, say how they're calculated, as clearly as the price itself, and show the number as soon as you can. A shipping estimate on the product page, based on location, beats a surprise on the last screen. For UK customers, show the minimum mandatory delivery charge in the total from the start.

Keep the running total visible through checkout

Show the order total on every step, updated as the customer makes choices. If the number at the end matches the number they've been watching, there's nothing left to explain.

The rest of your checkout: accessibility, cookies and security

A holiday checkout gets checked for more than its prices. Sale traffic brings more people using screen readers, keyboards and small phone screens, and a checkout they can't finish is a lost sale and a common source of ADA demand letters and lawsuits. Run your checkout pages through the free website accessibility checker, then work through the ADA website compliance checklist for the parts a tool can't judge, like whether every form error is announced. If you publish an accessibility statement, the accessibility statement generator gives you a draft to edit.

Checkout pages are also where tracking does the most damage. Pixels and session replay scripts on a payment page can capture exactly what a customer types. Use the cookie consent checker to see what loads before anyone makes a choice, and read our guide to CIPA risk from session replay and pixels before you add another marketing tag for the sale.

Payment pages need the right security headers too, because they're the pages an attacker most wants to inject a script into. The free security headers checker shows which headers a page sends and which are missing.

If you're an agency getting several client stores ready for the holidays, white-label compliance reports for agencies let you hand each client the findings under your own name.

Common questions

These are the questions we hear most from store owners and SaaS teams before a sale.

Is shipping a hidden fee?

It depends on where your customer is. Several US states, including California, Virginia and Colorado, let you leave reasonable shipping out of the advertised price, though California still counts handling fees. In the UK, the CMA expects the minimum mandatory delivery charge in the total price. If you can, show a shipping estimate early everywhere.

Do taxes have to be in the advertised price?

In most US states, no. The state laws above generally exclude government taxes and fees from the advertised total. In the UK and the EU, consumer prices are expected to include taxes.

Does the FTC fees rule apply to my online store?

Only if you sell live-event tickets or short-term lodging. A general store, a SaaS product or a retailer isn't covered by the Fees Rule. You're still covered by Section 5 of the FTC Act, which is what the Instacart, Greystar and Manchester City Nissan cases relied on, and by any state junk fee law where your customers live.

Does this apply to B2B or SaaS pricing?

The laws discussed here protect consumers, so pure business-to-business sales are generally outside them. A SaaS product sold to individuals is a consumer sale like any other, and Massachusetts's rule also covers trial offers and auto-renewals. If your pricing page serves both, the safe move is to show total prices to everyone.

Can I still show a price breakdown?

Yes. Showing what makes up the total is fine and often helpful. The rule is about which number comes first and stands out: the total has to lead, and the breakdown sits beneath it.

Are credit card surcharges drip pricing?

They can be. If paying by card is the only option, a card surcharge is effectively mandatory and belongs in the price under most total-pricing rules. Where customers have a cheaper way to pay, the rules differ by jurisdiction, so check the specific law before adding one.

This article is general information, not legal advice.

Get your checkout ready

You don't need a new checkout before the sale. You need the total price first, no surprises at the last step and every extra unticked. Most stores can do that in an afternoon.

Before Black Friday, scan your site free to check the pages around your checkout for deceptive design, accessibility, cookie consent and security problems, then run the 15-minute audit above by hand. For more context, there's more on dark patterns on our blog.

Sources

Sources used in this article
SourceWhat it supportsLink
FTC press release, December 17, 2024Announcement of the Fees Ruleftc.gov
Federal Register, January 10, 2025Final Fees Rule, 16 CFR Part 464govinfo.gov
FTC, Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees: FAQScope, requirements, vague fee labels, exclusionsftc.gov
Federal Register, September 15, 2026Civil penalty levels kept for 2026govinfo.gov
FTC, food and grocery delivery fees, April 2026Early-stage rulemaking noticeftc.gov
FTC, rental housing fees, March 2026Early-stage rulemaking noticeftc.gov
FTC, Instacart, December 18, 2025$60 million refundsftc.gov
FTC, Greystar, December 2, 2025$24 millionftc.gov
FTC, StubHub, April 9, 2026$10 million under the Fees Ruleftc.gov
FTC, Hopper, July 2, 2026$35 million, pre-selected feesftc.gov
FTC, Manchester City Nissan, August 19, 2026$4 millionftc.gov
FTC, Live Nation and Ticketmaster, September 18, 2025Pending lawsuit and allegationsftc.gov
California Attorney GeneralSB 478oag.ca.gov
Minnesota Revisor of StatutesMinn. Stat. 325D.44revisor.mn.gov
Virginia CodeVa. Code 59.1-607 to 59.1-609law.lis.virginia.gov
Massachusetts Attorney General940 CMR 38.00mass.gov
Colorado General AssemblyHB25-1090leg.colorado.gov
Oregon Governor's newsroomSB 430oregon.gov
Connecticut General AssemblyPublic Act 25-44cga.ct.gov
Illinois Governor's newsroomHB 228prezly.com
New York City Mayor's OfficeNYC hotel fee bannyc.gov
legislation.gov.uk, SI 2025/272DMCC consumer provisions from April 6, 2025legislation.gov.uk
legislation.gov.uk, DMCC Act section 230UK total price rulelegislation.gov.uk
CMA, AA and BSM, April 15, 2026First DMCC fine, refunds, 10% turnover powergov.uk
CMA, investigations, August 19, 2026Trainline, Virgin Atlantic, RED Driving Schoolgov.uk
CMA, open letter, November 2, 2026Mandatory delivery fees; enforcement totalsgov.uk
CMA207 guidanceUnfair commercial practices guidancegov.uk
European Commission, November 11, 2026Digital Fairness Act proposalcommission.europa.eu
CCPC, March 26, 2026EU Black Friday sweep of 314 tradersccpc.ie
Department for Business and Trade, September 4, 202346% of 525 providers; £595 million to £3.5 billion a yeargov.uk

This article is educational and reflects Sitejar's point of view. It is not legal advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified attorney.

All articles